Solace MUD Official Forum

Solace Development => Ideas => Topic started by: Tanis Half-Elven on January 13, 2008, 01:57:23 am



Title: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Tanis Half-Elven on January 13, 2008, 01:57:23 am
Proposed Map for Solace Area Rearrange:
http://i275.photobucket.com/albums/jj286/Tanis_HE/map_players.jpg

The goal of this rearrange is to have the solace world be similar to the Dragonlance world. The above map has all dragonlance locations properly placed, as would be shown in books.

The rearrange will not occur all at once. I it will happen in a number of small batches.

NOTE: Any area that does not appear on the map will have the EXACT same link to the world as it did before the rearrange.
For Example: Naiadia is not on the map; however, Naiadian Sea is on the map. Naiadia will connect to Naiadian sea as usual.
Another Example: Snowy Mountains is not on the map; however, eastern road is on the map. Snowy mountains will connect to the eastern road as usual.

NOTE: Some areas are moving, but will remain in Solace as "hidden areas". Although these areas are moving, they have not been shown on the area rearrange map. These areas include: Thorbardin, Isle of the Dead, Xak Tsaroth

----------------
Some Other Details about the rearrange:

* Darken Woods is moving, but it was accidently not shown on the map. Darken Woods will be connecting to the Wailing Fens.

* The new road connecting to Vingaard mountains will connect at the spot where Sla-mori currently connects.

* There will still be boats from Palanthas to Naiadia.

* Note that Dragonarmy camp stays in it's exact same place. (The reason that Vingaard is shown south of HCT is because currently in the game there is a small space [one room] of vingaard mountain area between HCT and dragonarmy camp).



Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: unreal on January 13, 2008, 02:05:23 am
Not sure if there is any sense of it...
Where is an option "abstain"?  ;)

P.S.: Notice that if rearrange will happen - you should immediate rebuild fly_area.. Notice also that we're waiting for fly_area ghm.. abit too long.. and promise that it would be fast enough  ;)


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: omledufromage on January 13, 2008, 02:14:48 am
I like it.  ;)


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Tanis Half-Elven on January 13, 2008, 02:17:29 am
Not sure if there is any sense of it...
Where is an option "abstain"?  ;)

If you dont want to vote, simply don't vote. If you don't see any use of it, you may decide to click 'No' option.

But, here is some sense of it (as taken from immortal board):

Advantages:
- Our world will closely match the dragonlance world.
- Palanthas would become more central (rather than the current situation, in which everything spreads off east and south of palanthas, there will now be long stretch from Caergoth to Qualinost, with Palanthas in the middle).
- Qualinost will become a much busier city.
- Caergoth will become slightly more important than it is right now.
- Cobar corral would become slightly easier to access.
- All hometowns would be easier to access.

Disadvantages:
- The surroundings of Palanthas would become less dense (currently there are tons of areas jammed right around palanthas; in the new world, a few of these areas would be moved away).
- Nethosak would become more isolated because it would only be accessable by boat. Nobody can walk there.
- The players will need to adjust to the new world, and although they once voted to rearrange areas (on homepage), they might not like it after it is finally rearranged.

Please take something into consideration: Players adjusting to the new world might be a good thing! Many times hero players log in, with nothing to do. Now these players will have a few new areas to explore (we are building many new areas for this), and they will need to spend time finding a few areas that have moved.

Quote
P.S.: Notice that if rearrange will happen - you should immediate rebuild fly_area.. Notice also that we're waiting for fly_area ghm.. abit too long.. and promise that it would be fast enough  ;)

Fly area is set up differently than before. It is quite easy to edit now. Fly area will not close at all if rearrange occurs.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Kage on January 13, 2008, 02:23:00 am
Please take something into consideration: Players adjusting to the new world might be a good thing! Many times hero players log in, with nothing to do. Now these players will have a few new areas to explore (we are building many new areas for this), and they will need to spend time finding a few areas that have moved.
- Great idea.  No matter how much people complain this will stimulate all to check it out, even old crabby ones cant resist.  All change is inevitable ask entropy  :P 


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Rialon on January 13, 2008, 02:57:14 am
Sure, as long as none of the areas will be lost and a basic map will be available.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Matthew on January 13, 2008, 03:18:55 am
Can i make a suggestion, add a road around each city so as to avoid entering one at all if you don't want to..


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Kage on January 13, 2008, 03:27:06 am
- I dont like that. In my opinion makes it too easy to avoid hardships of criminal life and pk dodging.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Rialon on January 13, 2008, 03:36:58 am
More sense for warder or cobar rp imho.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: omledufromage on January 13, 2008, 03:37:24 am
I must agree with Kage... one of the reasons because I think it makes no sense. Others Kage already mentioned.
Look at it this way, the guys who build the city won't be incentivated to build a road around it for the Warders or Cobar, they would mostly think "f*ck the Warders, f*ck the Cobar. If they don't want to enter the city, they find themselves a way around it. "


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Kage on January 13, 2008, 03:38:34 am
- hard enough to set traps and hunt runners without a backdoor too


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: omledufromage on January 13, 2008, 03:56:51 am
"all roads lead to Rome"... none lead around it *chuckle*  ;D


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Quino on January 13, 2008, 04:05:17 am
I don't see my favourite Shadowdale/Drannor ::)
Will they stay unmoved?


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Caleb on January 13, 2008, 04:09:56 am
shadowdale and myth drannor are forgotten realms, not dragonlance.
100% sure they are staying tho


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Quino on January 13, 2008, 04:14:35 am
Lame me, did not read Tanis's note carefully. Now I understand


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Matthew on January 13, 2008, 04:26:03 am
Will the inn of last home be east of Qualinost, maybe add Solace as a city? It is strange to call the mud Solace but have only the inn of last home... Also Qualinost should be half forest/grassed area and not all 'CITY'.

PS. Adding roads around the cities will do none of the things you suggest, and they couldn't possibly 'find' their own way around the city if there is none coded.

Actually i also wanted to suggest making the guards in the Solamnic cities a bit stronger...

If you want it to make sense, read warders 'laws'.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Tanis Half-Elven on January 13, 2008, 04:36:54 am
I don't see my favourite Shadowdale/Drannor ::)
Will they stay unmoved?

Well I guess I'll spoil small secret..... A side note about western road:
Shadowdale/drannor are not moving, but, there is another large change nearby, and a different area on western road is moving. This is not shown on the map because it is happening regardless of the votes made here. In fact, you will see the western road changes next reboot!

---

Will the inn of last home be east of Qualinost, maybe add Solace as a city?

Without Solace we really have no real place for Inn of the Last Home. At the same time, nobody wants to remove this nice area. So, it will be kept on eastern road. It's a shame about that, but maybe we'll build solace one day, and it can be moved too.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Valeria on January 13, 2008, 05:20:08 am
I must agree with Kage... one of the reasons because I think it makes no sense. Others Kage already mentioned.
Look at it this way, the guys who build the city won't be incentivated to build a road around it for the Warders or Cobar, they would mostly think "f*ck the Warders, f*ck the Cobar. If they don't want to enter the city, they find themselves a way around it. "

Yes, but in "truer"  rp, the warder and cobar themselves would have found/created ways around the cities. So while citybuilders do not build roads around them, it is the others who do. 

Here is another thought, if there is to be no paths around cities for those who would rather not enter (those of nature), then make connections between cities be more forest.  Now they are all non camo/non chameleon areas.  I think it would be more appropriate to make them camo/chameleon areas, with no hiding (sorry thieves and assassins).  In the dragonlance books, many times our heroes were ambushed in forest areas between cities.  So the warders and cobar would say, to bad for the city dwellers who choose to travel between cities, they do so at their own risk.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Kage on January 13, 2008, 05:33:02 am
- Only rp way I could come up for this situation is forest areas like flight areas..but this is too much code I imagine.  Like a forestwalk skill for druids and rangers or pathfinding skill for warders and cobar.  Whereby they find hidden trails in uncivilized wooded areas.  For example a forest route from woods south of palanthas to woods south of crossroads but Im just playing devil's advocate against myself I suppose.  I dont think its a great idea.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: omledufromage on January 13, 2008, 05:46:25 am
Valeria, you have a point... but then it wouldn't be a road as suggested earlier.
Actually... Kage's idea I find interesting, although I do not wish to give to much work for the coders. I also like Valeria's idea to make more forest in between the cities. Lots of places should be roads in the middle of a forest... so its still a forest, but you see a path in it so you won't get lost.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Matthew on January 13, 2008, 06:24:54 am
Perhaps i shall reword my suggestion because it seems it was not understood. By 'roads around the cities' i mean access to all area's without entering a city. Meaning a little more complicated road network, rather than a literal 'road' around the city... though in some cases it might not be avoided... I do not consider Qualinost as such a 'city' as it is suppose to be a forest city... and one i think warders should be able to enter.

PS. Warders current location is silly. You absolutely must either ride your griffon (which sucks for people who need other pets) or walk through Kalaman along a huge long road to the crossroads to get to all major enemies... Warders should be south of your current xroads or north of it in your 'new' forests, KoT near Sanction, Tower in wayreth.

PPS. Need solace? I will build it... take me maybe two weeks... wayreth and its forest area too if you like the tower idea....


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Caleb on January 13, 2008, 11:24:00 am
think about wayreth. As i came to realize earlier., no one can get through the forest
unless the mages allow it. So if we followed dragonlance and RP. TECHNICALLY no
one would ever be able to raid.

I think it should be built though :)
my two cents :)


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: dedraelos on January 13, 2008, 11:46:22 am
Was thinking the exact same thing, but in my opinion almost all clan areas are too basic and could be improved greatly. Why only one outer and one inner for each clan. Why not a small legion of solamnic knights. Or....at least something.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Matthew on January 13, 2008, 12:34:15 pm
I thought about that a little, not sure i really have a solution yet... i can't remember but didn't the forest revert to normal during the age of mortals?

EDIT: Aye, without normal magic and no highmage or master of the tower to renew the enchantment each month the forest reverted to normal and since the spell to enchant the forest was destroyed it could not be redone from scratch.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: moq on January 13, 2008, 07:13:19 pm
The Atlas of the Dragonlance World -- http://www.rapidshare.ru/533175

P.S. idk, probably this thing is copyrighted  :-)


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Quino on January 14, 2008, 12:12:34 am
I'd like to see dragonlance's slamori->pax hidden way, I have ideas where it should've been located.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Moon_Face on January 14, 2008, 09:59:06 pm
There are not so much people around to split them by long distance.
I know solace for almast ten years and all these years it was beatiful.
To keep it and to remember first builders we should not lose a heart of this world.

P.S. And if truth i do not like when new generation destroies things which were built by many people for many years. They never see a sense just because of low expirience.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: dedraelos on January 14, 2008, 10:45:51 pm
I also mourn people who desire to keep something wrong just because it's old. If there is an opportunity to change something to make it better, why not take advantage of it. Solace has many areas that are not related to dragonlance, and the map is wildly inconsistent with the world of Krynn. I've played Solace for about 7 years now and I applaud these endeavors whole heartedly.

Not everything new is bad. I don't support many new changes that will make the game too easy, but fighting change just because you got used to the way things used to be shows not lack of experience, but ignorance.

I don't mean that as personal attack Moon_Face, just disagree with your point of view with fervor.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Lizzy on January 15, 2008, 12:30:41 am
Just explain something to an OLD one - why must it BE like Dragonlance? Yes, it is BASED on Dragonlance, an idea is almost always based on something, but that doesn't mean it has to BE like the idea.

Ok. Fix up the areas, join them to other places so that it makes a bit more sense. Give it more of a connection - but it doesn't or shouldn't have to BE like Dragonlance. Remember, it is just BASED on Dragonlance. There are many other MUDS I am sure that are LIKE Dragonlance.

Solace had something unique. Lets not loose that uniqueness.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: dedraelos on January 15, 2008, 01:04:11 am
It doesn't have to be exactly like dragonlance, but what is wrong with reconstructing areas to make it more like a map of Krynn? The only thing I can see that might bother some people is the need to relearn where are few areas are and that doesn't seem like a reason to stop it. One reason to make it as close to dragonlance as possible is atmosphere. It is very much easier to create a "feeling" of the dragonlance world if the jarring mistakes are modified.

One of the main reasons I started playing Solace, and continue to this day is because I love the world of dragonlance so much. It's fun for me to visit places in the game that I read about in books, but for me, and I'm only speaking for myself, places from other games/books decrease the ambiance. I'd like to see some of the places like Myth Drannor, not taken away, but altered slightly to fit better into the world of Krynn.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Tanis Half-Elven on January 15, 2008, 11:42:20 pm
There are not so much people around to split them by long distance.

Distance may be slightly longer, but time taken to walk the distance will be shorter (unless you have memorized exact path, or use some sort of trigger). More importantly, the path will be much easier for new players to use; currently, without directions it would be nearly impossible for a newbie to find Nethosak. And also quite hard to find Qualinost.

P.S. And if truth i do not like when new generation destroies things which were built by many people for many years. They never see a sense just because of low expirience.

We still have active immortals who have been immortals for at least 8 years, and who were playing solace before that. And although this is not from the beginning of Solace's time, we also keep contact with the old immortals from even earlier times.

---

That being said; I understand that the world was built in a certain way, and that changing the world could have unforseen effects. However, I also always felt that the world was not perfect, and that an area such as nethosak was placed in haste, rather than in pre-meditated thought.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Lizzy on January 16, 2008, 06:48:08 am
Changing the world to make more sense, to connect up senselessly placed areas and such is a good thing. But to make it like the book (no idea what that is like anyway) well, you could loose the uniqueness of Solace. What does Chemosh have to say about all the changes anyway, or doesn't he have a hand in the world anymore?

My "objections" for want of a better word, have nothing to do with finding precious items, as I have no idea where they are to start with. So rule out that one for me thanks. I am only a basic player when I do play. Why do I play then? As I keep saying - it is unique, it is a world different to other MUDS.

We hear so much about making it like that other game - ummm - Carrion Fields I think? Suggestions and ideas from another MUD makes it almost like it, a clone. Do we want a clone? Even a clone of Dragonlance books? Ok, use the concept of the areas maybe. Add them as new areas, but hey - send me a map and mark where to find the shinies!!!  ;D ;D



Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Caleb on January 16, 2008, 07:42:32 am
Oh dear jemma you never change.
It's understandable, i know you are just comming to know the world and now we are moving
it around, but everyone should know that a map has been made available to you. Anything
that isnt shown on the map merely means that it has stayed connected to whatever area
has been shown.

We also wouldnt be having a poll if it hadnt been agreed upon by all immortals.

Making it at least somewhat look like the dragonlance map DOESNT MAKE US AT
all like any other mud. All our areas are unique and unused in other muds, even
if it was the general same direction, areas can vary so much that it would make
it completely different anyways.

We will NEVER EVER be carrion fields. Hopefully one day the playbase, but other
then that i pray to god we enver are.

I personally hate that mud. I guess i never  truly gave it a chance, but tried it a few
times and got fed up and left


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Lizzy on January 16, 2008, 09:35:36 am
Oh dear jemma you never change.

I but everyone should know that a map has been made available to you. Anything
that isnt shown on the map merely means that it has stayed connected to whatever area
has been shown.


Ah, why change when something is so - perfect - like - meeeeeeeeeeee (ok ok. so I am ROFLMBO)

A map has been available to me? WHERE? WHEN? I must have missed the post!!! Send it to me again PLLLLLLZZZZZZZZZZZZ

Connect the dots - great. Make new areas ok. Fine. But keep the simplicity of the areas. Keep the uniqueness of Solace. Keep the originality. Just don't make is so like a book.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Matthew on January 16, 2008, 09:54:20 am
There are lots of good reasons to base Solace on dragonlance, for instance... It helps to enforce RP in many ways. An good example is quests based on adventures in the books, or area's containing what remains after such adventures which can give clues to solving quests. To solve such quests you need to have read the books, be quite clever or have very good friends who are one or the other.

As a newbie I entered solace because it was based on dragonlance. It was difficult to grasp the way area's were arranged and as there is no discernable timeline some questions i was asked in my first induction were almost impossible to answer correctly. One was 'From where do the Knights of Takhisis base thier attacks on Solamnia'. I thought about it for a minute cause my first answer would have been Storms Keep (i would so like to build that too :P) but i said Sanction, cause i knew there was no Storms Keep area in the game so therefore i thought he must mean the Sanction era. But that was wrong too! Anyways, alot of people come to solace because it is a dragonlance mud.

I have tried to get friends playing here who are also interested in dragonlance muds but they see new thalos and arkham and find out where silvanesti is and other things which are stray of dragonlance like pure elemental mages and pure necromancer mages which rule all and its to wierd for them. Its kind of embarrasing so i don't bother anymore.

PS. the map is at the begining of this topic


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: deda on January 21, 2008, 06:56:33 pm
Does it mean a pwipe?


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Tanis Half-Elven on February 12, 2008, 03:10:23 am
Does it mean a pwipe?

No.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Kstatida on December 14, 2014, 01:22:35 pm
- Only rp way I could come up for this situation is forest areas like flight areas..but this is too much code I imagine.  Like a forestwalk skill for druids and rangers or pathfinding skill for warders and cobar.  Whereby they find hidden trails in uncivilized wooded areas.  For example a forest route from woods south of palanthas to woods south of crossroads but Im just playing devil's advocate against myself I suppose.  I dont think its a great idea.

Every city has a way around it, it's natural. It has always been like that, at least for the large carts that bypass. It should not necessarily be a safe way though.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Kstatida on December 14, 2014, 01:25:11 pm
Nice new map by the way. The nicest feature is that popular ranking areas are located at the far locations through the map so more of the areas will be visited more frequently.


Title: Re: Official Poll: Solace Area Rearrange
Post by: Kstatida on December 14, 2014, 01:30:39 pm
What does Chemosh have to say about all the changes anyway

He would like the idea, at least I have heard the similar thoughts from him more than once.