About punishment...

[yenge]

 

[kender]

do not whine

items of killed criminal its property of guardian clan
and they are free to spare it back or sacrifice
they have chosen one way of enlisted above
what the problem?

[hugo]

I find that odd.

If a Heretic used magic in front of an Immortal..
If a Takhisis member assisted an elf out of good will...
If an Entropy member.. uh, roleplayed..
If a Tower member gave a Heretic a kiss..

They would most certainly all be kicked out of their clans. Why is this one not kicked out? It's not only a violation of the Law, but also a direct opposite to the clans philosphy. Accident or not, I have seen people kicked out of clans for less.

[kender]

do not whine

items of killed criminal its property of guardian clan
and they are free to spare it back or sacrifice
they have chosen one way of enlisted above
what the problem?

[Quino]

Hmm, when I started as Guardian I made lots of such mistakes, each time called guards, removed all and suicided.
Moreover, it's possible that he just *mixed up* and wanted to attack near outer guard.

It happens, time will pass and he will learn.

By the way, Yenge, wasn't Enno attacking in city when he was about to induct in Guardians?

[yenge]

 

[kender]

it depends on what team to immortal belongs

[Nierth]

My imho: If I were a Guardian, I'd say to Eowiriand: do not put your nose into Guardians business in game exactly.  You're from Chaos in game, yenge, do not forget it and do not learn them in game how to act, it's not a chaotic RP. 

And one more hint - Forum is ooc, how could you imagine Imms to judge in-game, resting upon ooc information?

But, Scinc, you're doing something wrong, very wrong.

[Rialon]

Hmm... Which immortal told you that, Yenge? Only one you should listen to is immortal leader of Guardians. Majere at the time, if i am not mistaken. And yes of course, if High Counsellor thought it was a fair punishment, then no other, then the immortal leader can proove otherwise.
Having said that, as a player i do think that a guardian should get a punishment more harsh, then simple death. Uninduction included.

[Durewn]

Damn? nothing changes. When I was leader of guardians in long past all was the same, the Motto was "Guardi pidorasi" (it is quote sorry for swearing). And I had constant insults towards me like that: You crime wrong, you punish wrong, yu do everything wrong. But I can tell you it is useless. Guardians watched by immortals more then other clan, but our job hard and I think we are alowed to do some "unaccepteble things by some scociety members". E.g. Crime and punish our members only by death.
That times the leaders of opposition was Borric (strange guy that tryed to kill guards with all his chars after i kicked him from the Guardians) now it is yenge.
Nothing changes

Ahh no, I realy hate the last change of bunishing evil souls from guardians. :-)

And Morlag keep going, majority on your side :-)