boneshatter

[dedraelos]

You land a sudden crushing blow on Bizou's wrist!
Your boneshatter misses Bizou.
Bizou has some small wounds.

affect doesn't land, but I succeeded and missed?

[Quino]

affect landed but he avoided damage due to AC
I think this should work this way nonetheless because there's no sane hitroll vs AC check. (imho)

[dedraelos]

affect didn't land in his affects though.

[Quino]

Then it's up to immortals to decide

[Matthew]

You land a sudden crushing blow on Bizou's wrist! <-- You successfully completed the action
Your boneshatter misses Bizou. <-- His armor prevented it working

[Quino]

You land a sudden crushing blow on Bizou's wrist! <-- You successfully completed the action
Your boneshatter misses Bizou. <-- His armor prevented it working

That's what is quite logical...
...BUT there's no place for logic when we speak about ac until hr vs ac is rewritten.

[Kiri-Jolith]

It was fixed this way long time ago. Cannot penetrate AC => cannot land an affect.